What’s the best brand of spiced rum for making eggnog?

 

 

Makes no difference.

Haha, I’m not one for mixing alcohol and dairy, but this stuff makes a nice dark and stormy. 

Captain Morgan

14 minutes ago, dirtybeacher said:

Haha, I’m not one for mixing alcohol and dairy, but this stuff makes a nice dark and stormy. 

Figures that would be the first one mentioned. Kraken is horrible. We did serve it at Christmas a few years ago and pretty much everyone commented on the terrible taste.

Next.

 

The says Sailor Jerry but I almost positive we stroked it off the list a few years ago.

whats left? Bacardi, Captain Morgan, ?

 

Did find this on the LCBO shelf. I didn’t know you could sell such high % in Canada.

 

Haha, 7 yr old (or older if you can find) Havana club dark is my go to.   I prefer to use Mexican coke in my cubatas.  I don’t think I’ve ever had a rum an egg nog. 

None. Use appleton estates 12 year old and try diffetent recipes to find the one you prefer, then add to that, more rum and some high quality ice cream and blend it.

Lamb's Spiced was pretty good I think. Not a big fan but it didn't have that cotton candy/blown out candle after taste. That Sailor Jerry stuff is fn narsty

Does it really matter after 3?

5 hours ago, Renegade X said:

Does it really matter after 3?

Only matters for the first round.  

On 12/3/2019 at 10:25 PM, Blackstar said:

Only matters for the first round.  

Captain it is then

The best rum kraken, the best egg nog circle K ,  ORGASM  in a glass just say'in.

Funny I had some of this the other day, good shit

 

https://www.lcbo.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/en/lcbo/gift-and-sampler-packs-15021-1/evan-williams-eggnog-185884#.Xepy-JNKiM8

2 hours ago, Tinker said:

Funny I had some of this the other day, good shit

 

https://www.lcbo.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/en/lcbo/gift-and-sampler-packs-15021-1/evan-williams-eggnog-185884#.Xepy-JNKiM8

I don't know how anyone can drink eggnog? Same goes for butter milk!! 

17 minutes ago, irv said:

I don't know how anyone can drink eggnog? Same goes for butter milk!! 

I like the nog but I usually splash it with some milk to thin it a bit.

buttermilk?  Pass.

22 minutes ago, irv said:

I don't know how anyone can drink eggnog? Same goes for butter milk!! 

x100

If Nog tasted like Buttermilk I would hate it too. That's bad nog.

I've never tried eggnog or buttermilk so my rum is safe lol.